Marketing Consultant or Permanent Hire: A Strategic Decision

For many growing businesses, one question comes up time and again: should we hire a permanent marketer, or should we bring in a marketing consultant?

This is rarely a philosophical debate. It is a practical one, shaped by budget, ambition, speed, and how critical marketing is to hitting wider business objectives.

The honest (and perhaps obvious) answer is that both options are valid. A permanent hire can be the backbone of a marketing function. A consultant, on the other hand, is often the catalyst that gets things moving quickly and in the right direction. The key is knowing when each makes sense.

Think of it like a football transfer. Sometimes you invest in a young prospect with potential, knowing they will need time, coaching and patience for results. Other times you sign an experienced player who can step straight into the starting eleven and change the team's fortunes immediately. A marketing consultant is usually the latter.

This article looks at the scenarios where hiring a marketing consultant is the smarter move, when a permanent hire is the right long‑term choice, and why consultants are increasingly used across digital marketing, branding and martech.

Consultants: A Normalised & Proven Choice

Hiring consultants is no longer an exception. It is common practice across businesses of all sizes.

Recent UK and global research shows:

• Around half of UK businesses outsource some part of their marketing activity, particularly strategy, digital marketing and specialist execution.

• Surveys reported by Consultancy.uk have shown that more than 80% of mid-sized and large organisations use consultants and are satisfied with the results.

• Market research firms such as Mordor Intelligence forecast the global marketing consulting market to grow strongly through to 2030, with digital marketing consulting as the largest segment.

• External specialists are frequently shown to deliver outcomes faster than newly formed internal teams, particularly for transformation projects and complex implementations.

These figures reflect a simple reality. Marketing has become broader, more technical and more accountable to revenue. Many businesses cannot justify hiring full-time specialists for every need, but they still need senior expertise.

What a Marketing Consultant Actually Brings

A good marketing consultant is not a pair of extra hands. They are usually brought in to solve a defined problem or accelerate progress toward a clear objective.

• Ready-to-go Experience: Consultants are typically hired for what they already know. They have seen similar challenges before and understand what works, what does not, and what tends to fail quietly six months later.

  In football terms, this is not a youth academy signing. It is an experienced midfielder who knows how to control the tempo of the game from day one.

  This is especially valuable in areas like digital performance marketing, brand positioning or CRM and marketing automation, where mistakes are expensive and learning curves are steep.

  
  

• Speed & Momentum: Permanent hires take time to recruit, onboard and fully trust. Consultants are expected to deliver value quickly. They are often productive within weeks, sometimes days.

  For businesses under pressure to grow pipeline, launch a product, fix performance issues or justify investment, this speed can make a meaningful difference.

  
  

• Objectivity & Perspective: Internal teams can struggle to challenge long‑standing assumptions, particularly in founder-led or fast-growing businesses. A consultant brings an external perspective, informed by work across different sectors and stages of growth. They can ask the awkward questions early, before time and budget are committed in the wrong places.

  
  

• Flexibility Without Long-Term Risk: Consultants scale up and down with your needs. You pay for expertise when you need it, rather than carrying fixed costs year-round. This flexibility is attractive when marketing demand fluctuates, or when leadership teams are still working out how central marketing should be to future growth.

  
  

The Sweet Spot: When a Consultant Makes the Most Sense

Not every business, or every situation, is right for a consultant. The biggest factor is not company size, but clarity of objectives.

Here are some common scenarios where consultants consistently add more value than a permanent hire.

Business scenario	When a consultant is the better option	When a permanent hire fits better
Early-stage startup	Defining positioning, testing channels, building first strategy	Once channels are proven and execution is ongoing
Scale-up business	Accelerating growth, fixing funnel leaks, specialist input	When marketing becomes operational and repeatable
Rebrand or reposition	Strategic direction and external perspective	Post-rebrand delivery and consistency
Martech implementation	CRM, automation and analytics expertise	Ongoing platform management
Short-term growth targets	Immediate impact and accountability	Long-term team building

If marketing is central to growth but the path is still being defined, a consultant often provides clarity faster than a new hire who is still learning the business.

Consultant vs Permanent Hire: A Practical Comparison

One of the biggest objections to consultants is cost. Day rates can look high at first glance, particularly when compared to a salary.

The comparison changes when you look at the full picture.

Consideration	Marketing consultant	Permanent hire
Cost structure	Pay for agreed scope and outcomes	Salary, benefits, tax and overheads
Speed to impact	Fast, often immediate	Slower ramp-up
Specialist depth	High and focused	Broader, often generalist
Flexibility	Easy to scale up or down	Fixed commitment
Hiring risk	Low and time-bound	High if role or fit is wrong
Long-term continuity	Limited without extension	Strong internal knowledge

When businesses factor in recruitment fees, onboarding time, management overhead and the cost of a wrong hire, consultants often represent better short-term value.

Addressing the Day Rate Question Honestly

Day rates often attract the most scrutiny. On paper, a consultant charging £500 per day can feel expensive when compared to a permanent salary. The comparison becomes more balanced when the full cost and realistic utilisation of a permanent hire are taken into account.

A consultant’s day rate reflects experience, speed, and accountability for outcomes. It also includes costs that a business would otherwise carry itself, such as training, tools, professional development, insurance and downtime between projects.

A permanent hire, by contrast, comes with additional costs beyond salary. These typically include employer National Insurance, pension contributions, benefits, recruitment fees, management time and the risk of underutilisation.

An Illustrative Example

A marketing consultant charging £500 per day, working 2 days per week for 46 weeks of the year, would cost around £46,000 annually.

A permanent hire on a £45,000 salary can easily cost £60,000 to £65,000 per year once employer NI, pension contributions, benefits and recruitment costs are included.

Beyond cost-effectiveness, another key difference is utilisation. The consultant is paid only for the days they are needed and is expected to deliver defined outcomes in that time. The permanent hire must be fully utilised year-round to justify their cost, which is not always realistic, particularly in smaller teams or businesses with fluctuating marketing needs.

When output is measured against cost, rather than salary against day rate, consultants often represent better value during periods where expertise is needed, but not every single day.

The Temp-to-Perm Middle Ground

For businesses unsure about long-term needs, a temp-to-perm approach can work well.

This involves bringing in a consultant or contractor initially, with a view to converting to a permanent role if the impact is clear and the workload justifies it.

It allows businesses to test the role, understand the skills required, and assess cultural fit before committing. In many cases, it leads to stronger permanent hires because expectations are clearer on both sides.

Why Consultants Excel in Digital, Brand and Martech

Consistency in design is vital for building brand recognition. When your marketing materials look and feel the same, it reinforces your brand identity. Here are some tips for maintaining consistency:

• Digital Marketing: Digital channels move quickly. Consultants bring tested frameworks, benchmarks and performance insight from across multiple accounts, helping businesses avoid expensive trial and error.

  
  

• Brand: Brand work benefits from distance. Consultants are often better placed to challenge internal narratives and help businesses articulate what truly differentiates them.

  
  

• Martech: CRM and marketing automation projects regularly fail due to lack of expertise. Consultants who specialise in these platforms can implement faster and more reliably, then hand over a system that works.

  
  

Summary

Hiring a marketing consultant is not about avoiding permanent talent. It is about using the right resource at the right time.

Consultants are at their best when businesses need clarity, speed and experienced leadership without long-term risk. Permanent hires are invaluable once direction is set and consistent execution is required.

Pointing to another football analogy; hiring consultants help you stabilise the game, raise standards and get results on the board. Permanent hires help you build a squad for the future, and knowing when to bring each in is what separates reactive marketing decisions from strategic ones.

About the Author

Jack Scorgie is a marketing consultant with 20 years

of experience working across financial services,

energy, and a range of B2B and B2C industries.

He specialises in developing brands, building digital strategies, and implementing bespoke martech solutions that support measurable business growth.

GO BACK TO SITE